Asia Pacific REITs - Long-term fundamentals should not be overshadowed by short-term flux

Chart 1: Defensive properties of AP REITs¹

During these times, we believe that fundamentals matter more than ever. Our focus remains on capital strength, the pedigree of the sponsor, and drilling down to the details of lease terms and structure.

We also think that AP REITs are better positioned to face the current economic downturn than they were after the global financial crisis (GFC). Stronger balance sheets mean that the risk of REITs breaching debt covenants is lower, which suggests that the need for dilutive equity fund raising will be minimised.

We believe that AP REITs are more robust in three main areas:

• A decade of low interest rate has reduced the cost of debt in major regional REITs.
• AP REITs have generally locked in financing costs for a longer time period, which has reduced the risks associated with short-term refinancing – an issue that that plagued REITs during the GFC.
• Lower overall leverage ratios and diversified funding sources has also decreased the risk of covenant breaches.

Lower interest rates as key tailwind

Although this economic environment will inevitably pose challenges to AP REITs, particularly in the hotel and retail sectors, as well as REITs with a high exposure to small-and-medium enterprises (SME), we believe the asset class is still better positioned than it was during the GFC.

Historically, AP REITs have outperformed equities during periods of low interest rates (see Chart 2), which we have re-entered after the simultaneous demand-and-supply shocks imposed by the global spread of COVID-19.

One of the main factors underpinning this outperformance is expanding yield spreads.  A yield spread is the difference between the yield on, for example, a risk-free instrument (such as US Treasuries) and the yield offered by other issues. As risk-free rates move lower – they have been aggressively cut over the past month – investors are being compensated more for assuming risk.

Chart 2: AP REITs historically perform well in a low interest-rate environment²

Total Return (from 31 December 2008 – 31 December 2015)

Chart 3: Expanding yield spreads³

Chart 3 shows yield spreads in the key AP REIT markets – Australia, Hong Kong, and Singapore – from the beginning of 2020 through early March: yield spreads have widened in all three, as the risk-free rate has fallen.

We believe that lower interest rates and the global search for yield among investors will continue to support the asset class.

Resilient spots emerge in AP REITs

Although REITs do have qualities that are defensive in nature, we believe that no segment in the REIT space should be considered “recession-proof”.  

Given the current economic environment and recent government directives, there will be temporary disruption, particularly in the consumption and tourism-related industries. This has resulted in downward revisions to DPU estimates for 2020.  However, we do believe that these revisions have been fully priced into share prices, as yield spreads are trading well above their 10-year averages⁴.

Investors may find opportunities in the following segments:

Singapore

• Retail
  Short-term dislocation is expected to impact Singapore’s retail sector due to government measures.  While this may result in some near-term downside, the long-term fundamentals of the segment remain resilient for the following reasons:
  1. Retail space per capita in Singapore is lower than several developed markets, which highlights that the market is not yet oversupplied⁵.
  2. The government tightly regulates land supply and use. The lower increase in retail space safeguards against oversupply in the market.
  3. Given population density and the convenience of shopping malls, a physical retail presence is expected to remain highly relevant in Singapore.

Hong Kong

• Retail
  Hong Kong’s retail sector has battled numerous challenges over the past year, leading to a precipitous fall in retail sales.  We believe that the market has priced in a significant amount of negative news flow, and that shopping malls providing necessary goods for consumers should remain resilient in the current challenging economic environment. 

Australia

• Office
  We are constructive on Grade A office space in the Sydney CBD area, as demand is not expected to significantly deteriorate while new supply is forecast to be limited over the next two years. 
• Industrial
  Overall, we believe that third-party logistics and ecommerce providers should digest existing local supply. The increased utilisation of online shopping during the COVID-19 outbreak should be catalyst in this segment. 

Conclusion

AP REITs are not immune from the economic fallout from the spread of COVID-19. However, the defensive characteristics of the asset class suggest that investors should benefit from their hybrid nature. At the same time, the fundamentals of AP REITs, including relatively robust performance in low interest-rate environments and an improved financial position, augurs a greater resiliency compared to other investments.

Download full PDF

1 Source: Bloomberg, 31 March 2020.

2 Bloomberg, as of 30 November 2019.  Gross total returns in US dollar. Past performance is not indicative of future performance. Australia REIT – S&P/ASX 200 A-REIT Index, Hong Kong REIT – Hang Seng REIT Index, Singapore REIT – FTSE ST Real Estate Investment Trusts index, Asia ex Japan REITs = FTSE EPRA/NAREIT Asia ex Japan REITs Index, Singapore Equities = Straits Times Index STI Total Return Index, Hong Kong Equities= Hang Seng Index, Australia Equities = S&P/ASX 200 index, Asia ex Japan equities= MSCI AC Asia Ex Japan index (total return). 

3 Source: Bloomberg, 31 March 2020.

4 Source: Bloomberg, 31 March 2020. Singapore REITs = FSTREI Index, 10 year Singapore government bond. Australia REITs = AS51PROP Index, 10-year Australian government bond. Hong Kong REITs = HSREIT Index, 10-year HK government bond (data as of May 2012).

5 CapitaLand Investor Day 2019, 29 November 2019.